Assessing the Essaying Journey

Higher Education Assessment Guide

Assessing the Essaying Journey

A six-module guide for making student thinking more visible and essay assessment more meaningful.

6 Modules β€’ Copyable LMS Templates β€’ Calibration Guides

πŸ“– Overview: Moving beyond detection to better assessment design.

Generative AI has exposed a fundamental challenge in traditional higher education assessment: we have often treated the final written product as evidence of the learning process itself. When chatbots can generate fluent 2,000-word essays in seconds, relying on AI detection software becomes an unwinnable arms race and can unfairly disadvantage multilingual learners.

This guide offers an evidence-based alternative. Drawing on the original idea of the essay as a process of inquiry, it explores how assessment can be redesigned to make learning visible through drafts, checkpoints, reflections, contextual evidence, and informed academic judgement.

πŸ“š Modules and Resources

Select a module below to explore the ideas in more detail, including practical design strategies, assessment examples, prompt redesigns, and resources that can be adapted for your own teaching context.

Module 1

Rethinking Essay Assessment: From Product to Process

Why AI detection falls short, how traditional essay assessment became vulnerable, and why making the learning process visible matters.

Read Module 1 β†’
Module 2

Scaffolding the Essay Process: Four Assessment Checkpoints

Scaffolding the essay process through four assessment checkpoints, from establishing a baseline voice and refining research questions to drafting, reflection, and oral discussion..

Read Module 2 β†’
Module 3

Looking for Evidence of Learning

Using the Two-Highlighter Technique to identify evidence of learning across student drafts, reflections, and assessment checkpoints..

Read Module 3 β†’
Module 4

Designing Better Essay Prompts

Practical strategies for redesigning essay prompts using course-specific resources, local contexts, and opportunities for students to demonstrate how their thinking develops over time.

Read Module 4 β†’
Module 5

Rubrics, Calibration and Evaluative Judgement

Moving beyond checklist rubrics towards holistic assessment, marker calibration, and the development of student evaluative judgement.

Read Module 5 β†’
Module 6

Putting It Into Practice: Templates and Resources

Practical templates and resources, including subject outline statements, AI-use logs, interactive oral assessment guides, and peer review activities..

Read Module 6 β†’

πŸ“₯ Guide Downloads & Printable Assets

Use these companion visual assets and printable PDF guides to support your faculty workshops and subject redesigns:

πŸ“„ Mind Map PDF Handout

Landscape 1-page summary of writing as a cognitive catalyst.

Download PDF β†’

πŸ—ΊοΈ Essay Journey Infographic

Student-facing roadmap showing the 4 assessment checkpoints.

View Infographic β†’

πŸ“‹ LMS Marking Rubric Matrix

Copyable rubric for holistic grading and process logs.

Access Rubric β†’

Assessing the Essaying Journey β€’ Designed for Higher Education Educators.